Comparison

MaX Thyroid and Total Thyroid #2

MaX Thyroid (XYMOGEN) lists 24 distinct ingredients and Total Thyroid #2 (Nutri-West) 30 (rows of one ingredient counted once); 20 are on both labels. On the site's similarity measure, which compares ingredient lists (1 for the same list, rarer ingredients counting for more; amounts are not part of it), the two formulas score 0.51.

Amount per serving (and % of the Daily Value)
IngredientMaX ThyroidTotal Thyroid #2
Vitamin C100 mg (111%)50 mg (56%)
Calcium25 mg (2%)25 mg (2%)
Vitamin B610 mg (588%)5 mg (294%)
Vitamin B12100 mcg (4167%)100 mcg (4167%)
Zinc5 mg (45%)1.5 mg (14%)
Niacin5 mg (31%)2 mg (13%)
Folate100 mcg100,000 mcg
Vitamin A1,005 IU505 IU
Riboflavin10 mg (769%)5 mg (385%)
Thiamin10 mg (833%)5 mg (417%)
Selenium25 mcg (45%)200 mcg (364%)
Manganese0.8 mg (35%)0.8 mg (35%)
Iodine50 mcg (33%)1,530 mcg (1020%)
Choline100 mg (18%)25 mg (5%)
Tyrosine50 mg50 mg
Adrenals10 mg10 mg
Thymus40 mg40 mg
Spleen10 mg10 mg
Pituitary3 mg3 mg
Parotid3 mg3 mg
Vitamin E30 IU
Molybdenum30 mcg (67%)
Ashwagandha200 mg
Eleuthero20 mg
Betaine Hydrochloride75 mg
Glutamic Acid20 mg
Gotu Kola5 mg
Betaine25 mg
Guggul25 mg
Coleus25 mg
American Ginseng20 mg
Yellow Dock5 mg
Arabinogalactan100 mg
Thyroid100 mg

Amounts are per serving as DSLD gives them: MaX Thyroid, 1 capsule; Total Thyroid #2, 1 tablet. Current labels entered January 2017 and January 2014. Percentages of the Daily Value from 21 CFR 101.9. Source: NIH ODS Dietary Supplement Label Database.

Each product on its own